Free lunches, mind breaks and pleased lecturers: why Estonia has one of the best colleges in Europe | Life and elegance


Today’s topic within the sci-fi class at Pelgulinna State Gymnasium is Blade Runner. Thursdays are “voluntary” lesson days, the place college students at this higher secondary faculty in Estonia’s capital, Tallinn, can select from a spread of topics; others going down right now embody a rights and democracy course, programming and artistic writing in English. The seven 17-year-old college students within the sci-fi lesson have simply completed watching half-hour of the movie and are making ready to debate it after I sneak in on the again, switching to excellent English for my profit. “We’ve talked about Jungian archetypes, persona and the superego,” says Triin, one of many college students. “It has been actually useful for me to grasp the completely different features of being human and the way to create deeper characters.” They’ve additionally studied Courageous New World and 2001: A House Odyssey. Within the couple of minutes I’m there, the scholars contact on US historical past, youngster labour, empathy and extra. “I’ve so many questions,” says Triin.

Me too. How did Estonia, a small nation that’s comparatively poor in contrast with many of the EU, turn out to be an academic powerhouse? Within the Organisation for Financial Co-operation and Improvement’s Programme for Worldwide Scholar Evaluation (Pisa) rankings, which measures 15-year-olds’ talents in maths, studying and science, the highest spots are held by a handful of Asian international locations, however Estonia ranks subsequent – one of the best in Europe. Its lecturers are extremely educated, the main focus is on social and private abilities as a lot as educational studying and the standard curriculum is full of a variety of topics, from robotics to music and humanities. British politicians are taking be aware. In 2022 Labour’s shadow training secretary, Bridget Phillipson, visited to see what Estonia is doing proper.

Gunda Tire, who leads worldwide assessments for Estonia’s training and youth board, says the nation’s success is partly due to its mixture of historical past and geography. “We’ve got had the Swedes, Danes, Russians, Germans, lots of people coming and going. Estonians, in the event that they wished to outlive, needed to be good, they usually understood that training would take them ahead. It was the identical after we had been beneath Soviet occupation.”

Gustav Adolf Grammar faculty the place youngsters get ‘mind breaks’. {Photograph}: Sandra Süsi

One of many abiding rules, she says, is equality – common free faculty lunches are as a lot ideological as they’re sensible. And virtually all youngsters attend kindergarten, which is closely subsidised, in order that by the point they begin faculty on the comparatively late age of seven, disadvantages aren’t as entrenched. Autonomy can also be basic. “We’ve got given colleges the power to determine for themselves.”

When Estonia embraced the digital age, colleges had been a part of that. Way back to 1997, the nation launched an initiative known as Tiigrihüpe (Tiger Leap), to improve pc assets and supply web entry to varsities. “We educated a number of lecturers, linked all the faculties and gave them computer systems,” says Tire. “The concept is to not have an IT class, however to have digital abilities included in all places.” Many youngsters be taught coding and robotics, and every thing from textbooks to communication with mother and father is digital. As an alternative of disruptive college students dealing with harsh self-discipline, says Tire, Estonian colleges are inclined to have a extra nurturing strategy – it’s common to take youngsters out and train them in a small group with a separate trainer, and most colleges have a psychologist and counsellor.

Inventive topics are simply as valued, Tire explains: “All of them must take arts and music, and [what we call] ‘expertise’ – in different phrases, they learn to cook dinner, knit, issues like that. If we permit children that, their wellbeing and sense of accomplishment will increase. We don’t assume that that’s irrelevant. Some international locations say: ‘We took out the music lesson to show extra maths.’ However have a look at a sheet of music and you’ll not assume it’s easier.” Inventive topics, Tire factors out, can foster every kind of abilities corresponding to teamwork and problem-solving. She smiles when she remembers watching teenage boys at a big pageant final 12 months enthusiastically collaborating in folks dances they’d discovered at college. “It’s a bodily exercise, offers you pleasure, and you might be in a bunch and have to make use of communication abilities.”

‘This technology wish to be included within the dialog’ … Pelgulinna State Gymnasium. {Photograph}: Hendrik Osula/The Guardian

To progress into higher secondary, the equal of sixth type, college students take simply three exams – maths, Estonian and a topic of their selection – fairly than the pressurised workload when taking many GCSEs within the UK. May you think about having to take eight or extra exams, I ask Cordelia Violet Paap, a 17-year-old pupil at Pelgulinna State. She seems to be shocked and says: “That’s loads. I’d be much more burdened.”

Paap says her faculty’s ethos of creativity “is much more gratifying than the very orthodox method, the place you simply sit in a classroom and hear.” To counter any notions that that is too liberal, Targo Tammela, 17, who has simply come from a Nordic historical past class, says there “remains to be self-discipline, you continue to must move each check.” Neither has significantly embraced Estonia’s much-admired digital training, however it’s nonetheless an enormous a part of their studying, they are saying. Tech is available, and most studying assets and assessments are on-line. “There are just a few cons, as a result of you may get lazy with it or get misplaced within the web,” says Tammela. “However the professionals outweigh it.”

It’s early afternoon and on the Gustav Adolf Grammar faculty within the outdated a part of Tallinn, the college day is already over for a lot of college students. I wait on the entrance gate for the headteacher and watch younger youngsters strolling off house by themselves, or with buddies. “They are typically very impartial,” says Henrik Salum, the (younger, jeans-wearing) head.

‘They are typically very impartial’ … a pupil at Gustav Adolf Grammar faculty. {Photograph}: Sandra Süsi

Behind the historic facade, the college – it educates youngsters aged seven to fifteen and this website is for the youthful college students – has been redeveloped, with loads of area and light-weight. There are punchbags in a single space, which can also be used for dance classes; desk tennis in one other. The massive central atrium, the place youngsters have their lunch, has a piano and a stage for performances. College students sit on the tiered step seating, doing schoolwork or chatting. The environment is pleasant and relaxed.

Are there behavioural issues? “In fact,” says Salum. “Every single day there’s some type of incident the place it’s important to speak to college students about the way to respect others and the way to behave. We’ve got sure college students we have to preserve a better eye on and we work with mother and father loads, however total I feel the scholars have a tendency to understand their setting.” It seems to be fairly harmonious to me. Two youngsters are enjoying chess in one of many broad corridors and there are neat piles of cushions in all places for use for socialising, or for every time one of many lecturers fancies a change of scene and desires to carry their lesson exterior the classroom.

In an Estonian class, there’s quiet as a bunch of eight and nine-year-olds work on their very own summaries of a guide they’ve simply learn, which is up on the massive display screen. In one other classroom, 12 and 13-year-olds are specializing in English vocabulary. There are simply 16 youngsters on this class. Class sizes are normally as much as 28 college students, however overseas languages are taught in smaller teams, so everybody has the possibility to talk and take part.

‘Common free faculty lunches are as a lot ideological as they’re sensible’ … the canteen at Pelgulinna State Gymnasium. {Photograph}: Hendrik Osula/The Guardian

In Maria Toom’s class of 10 and 11-year-olds, a number of the youngsters have stayed again to talk to me – all in wonderful English. What do they keep in mind of kindergarten? It was enjoyable, they are saying. “We had sleep breaks,” says one woman, Laura. Right here they get “mind breaks” as a substitute, she says – a number of occasions in a lesson, their trainer, identified by her first identify, will give them a break for a little bit of motion, or to play a sport.

“One of many key components of the Estonian academic system is that colleges and lecturers have a number of freedom,” says Salum. There are requirements they should meet, however how they obtain that’s as much as them. Toom has entry to tablets and laptops for the youngsters, however she is simply as more likely to take a lesson exterior, or on the roof terrace, with paper and pencil – to not research nature (though they try this, too), however as a result of it’s good to be taught maths outside. “I feel it offers freedom and it signifies that college students have the flexibleness to be taught in all places,” she says.

As we stroll across the faculty, each pupil says “tere” (hey) to Salum, and one woman comes as much as him and throws her arms round his center. “Some need a excessive 5,” he says. “So long as college students are smiling and saying hey then every thing is okay. In the event that they cease doing that, I do know I’m in hassle.” When Salum was at college, it was extra conventional however he says the scholars recognize a much less hierarchical environment. “We are inclined to view our college students as colleagues so we work collectively, we contain them.” Lots of the faculty’s lecturers are former pupils, which he likes.

Pelgulinna State Gymnasium is one among 13 new secondary colleges constructed by the state within the final 5 years. {Photograph}: Hendrik Osula/The Guardian

The principle drawback for Salum, and lots of different heads, is the shortage of lecturers. Regardless of the positives of the system, there are nonetheless workload and recruitment points. Why, when lecturers are required to have a grasp’s diploma (kindergarten lecturers should have a bachelor’s diploma), would they earn a relatively low wage after they might go right into a higher-paying job, corresponding to in Estonia’s wholesome digital business? Earlier this 12 months, Estonia’s lecturers held their first strike for a few years.

Academics’ pay “is an issue all around the world,” says Kristina Kallas, Estonia’s training minister, after I meet her in her workplace. “The training system is at all times beneath assets strain.” There are two important points for the time being, she says. “One is the financial recession, and the opposite is that any funds surplus goes to defence, as a result of we’re in a really precarious scenario.” All eyes are on Estonia’s neighbour, Russia, and the scenario in Ukraine.

Kallas thinks the power in Estonia’s training system is as a result of “it’s constructed from the bottom-up, not run by [central government], and it by no means was. The training system is older than the state.” Are there politicians who wish to have extra management over it? “Surprisingly not,” says Kallas. “All people leaves [education] to the consultants. Academics and universities debate it, typically publicly and there are arguments about whether or not it ought to be accomplished this manner or the opposite method, however it’s not the politicians.”

There are points that Kallas has her eye on. Through the pandemic, Estonian youngsters didn’t fare too badly as a result of they had been already effectively arrange for digital studying, however since then, there was a worrying variety of teenage boys dropping out. And though there isn’t an elite personal faculty system, higher-earning households typically transfer to be close to one of the best colleges, pushing others out. “This can be a development I don’t like as a result of it really works in opposition to the the explanation why our training system is robust – fairness is essential,” says Kallas.

‘If you happen to don’t click on with the scholars, it doesn’t matter what you do’ … Agne Kosk. {Photograph}: Hendrik Osula/The Guardian

Pelgulinna State Gymnasium is clearly one of many higher colleges. It solely opened final autumn – one among 13 new secondary colleges constructed by the state within the final 5 years, and it’s lovely, with the give attention to area, mild and pure supplies, particularly wooden. One room has rows of huge screens the place college students can work in small teams and share shows, and there are snug nooks constructed into the wall, full with energy factors, the place college students can cocoon themselves. There are additionally 300 bicycle parking areas, cool pink loos, bushes rising indoors and a cushty library. A small reminder that each one is just not completely excellent on this idyll is that this morning’s class within the lecture theatre, the place a number of military officers are providing “defence training”, together with preparation, communications and taking care of neighbours; these programs had been launched to Estonian higher secondary colleges final 12 months.

The lecturers use a mixture of practises, says Agne Kosk, head of languages, who was main the sci-fi course. “This technology wish to specific their opinion, they wish to be included within the dialog, to know all sides of the problems. Instructing by regurgitating a textbook doesn’t work any extra.” She says a very good relationship together with her college students “is primary. If you happen to don’t click on with the scholars, it doesn’t matter what you do”. Estonia’s training system appears significantly geared as much as nurturing that, from the casual and artistic strategy to the principally pleased lecturers.

In her sci-fi class, there’s clearly an awesome relationship – the scholars have created their very own hashtag, written on the whiteboard, which interprets as “Agne is cool”. Kosk asks them what notes they made after they watched the primary a part of Blade Runner, and this sparks a dialogue about whether or not or not they’d fail an empathy check (which might mark them out as one of many movie’s non-human replicants), what it means to be human and a bit about movie historical past (is that this, one of many college students asks, one of many first movies to have flying automobiles in it?). It’s time to look at some extra. Lights down – the scholars repair their consideration on the display screen.


Supply hyperlink

Leave a comment